Last week saw an unlikely first move in the opening narrative battle around a prospective U.S. central bank digital currency: Congressperson Tom Emmer came forward with an initiative to legally restrict the Federal Reserve’s capacity to issue a retail CBDC and take on the role of a retail bank. This could be massively consequential as we are yet to see a similarly sharp-cut expression of an opposing stance. As a matter of fact, it is not even clear whether other U.S. lawmakers have strong opinions on the matter other than, perhaps, condemning privately issued stablecoins as a digital alternative to the dollar. By framing a potential Fed CBDC as a privacy threat first, Emmer could tilt the conversation in the direction that is friendly to less centralized designs of digital money.Below is the concise version of the latest “Law Decoded” newsletter. For the full breakdown of policy developments over the last week, register for the full newsletter below.U.S. representative vs. U.S. CBDCThe tension between decentralized digital money and state-issued CBDCs is at the heart of the ongoing global shift toward digital payment rails. Last week marked the first-ever instance of a sitting U.S. member of Congress taking a formal stance against the Federal Reserve’s potential retail CBDC move.Sovereign digital fiat will undoubtedly be more convenient than its analog predecessor, yet the privacy costs of such convenience might be enormous. If all money is CBDC, the government’s financial surveillance capacity will become virtually unlimited, denying people the anonymity that cash transactions once afforded. Representative Emmer cited these privacy concerns as a rationale for introducing the bill that would ban the Fed from issuing a CBDC directly to consumers and acting as a retail bank.While it may take a long time before Emmer’s initiative reaches the House floor, the mere articulation of such a position by a member of Congress can have a significant impact on the course of the policy conversation around a potential CBDC. This is especially true in the light of some top Fed officials’ stated willingness to defer to Congress on the issue.Another ban scare, another El SalvadorElsewhere in the world, the signals that various regulators have been sending over the past week ran the gamut from potentially banning crypto transactions in Pakistan to considering the replication of El Salvador’s Bitcoin-as-legal-tender move in Tonga. Pakistan’s drive toward a blanket ban follows a familiar scenario where it is the nation’s central bank that is actively committed to outlawing crypto transactions and penalizing crypto exchanges. The task of determining the legal status of cryptocurrencies fell to the High Court of the province of Sindh, yet the judges refrained from making the final call and passed the issue on to the specialized government ministries. On the opposite side of the regulatory spectrum, the island nation of Tonga could be embarking on the Bitcoin adoption trail soon. An announcement by Lord Fusitu’a, a former member of the Tongan parliament and chairman of several regional interparliamentary groups, suggested that the country could make Bitcoin legal tender as soon as late 2022. Given Tongans’ heavy reliance on remittances, replicating El Salvador’s move almost identically seems logical.IMF sees the demise of crypto’s hedge roleAmong many risk factors that analysts ascribed to digital assets over the years, the financial stability risk that stems from crypto’s growing correlation with equity markets comes across as a novel talking point. Yet this is what a group of the International Monetary Fund researchers concluded upon examining the dynamics of Bitcoin to S&P 500 index correlation. The authors argued that the growing interconnectedness between the two asset classes defeats crypto’s hedge function, as it no longer serves to diversify investors’ risks. The IMF analysts’ conclusions come down to a reasonable notion that there should be a global, coordinated approach to crypto regulation.Čítaj viac
El Salvador’s historic embrace of Bitcoin (BTC) could have negative consequences on the country’s sovereign credit outlook, according to Moody’s Investors Service. Moody’s analyst Jaime Reusche told Bloomberg this week that El Salvador’s Bitcoin gambit “certainly adds to the risk portfolio” of a country that has struggled with liquidity issues in the past. Under the leadership of President Nayib Bukele, El Salvador has recognized Bitcoin as legal tender and issued a state-run crypto wallet to facilitate payments, transfers and ownership. Along the way, El Salvador has amassed a treasure chest of 1,391 BTC, with President Bukele famously “buying the dip” on several occasions by using Bitcoin’s volatility to add to his country’s holdings. Buying the dip 150 new coins added.#BitcoinDay #BTC— Nayib Bukele (@nayibbukele) September 7, 2021However, Reusche warned that accumulating more BTC would elevate El Salvador’s risk of default. “If it gets much higher, then that represents an even greater risk to repayment capacity and the fiscal profile of the issuer,” he said.PREDICTION: The El Salvador bitcoin bond will be ridiculously oversubscribed pic.twitter.com/2Kj0urm0SN— Pomp (@APompliano) November 23, 2021
In addition to downgrading El Salvador’s credit rating, Moody’s has warned that the country’s so-called Bitcoin volcano bond could limit its access to foreign bond markets. Proceeds of the volcano bond, which is expected to raise roughly $1 billion, will be used to fund El Salvador’s Bitcoin City project. Related: Tonga to copy El Salvador’s bill making Bitcoin legal tender, says former MPAttacks on El Salvador’s Bitcoin gambit by legacy financial institutions are nothing new. In November 2021, the Washington-based International Monetary Fund warned El Salvador against using Bitcoin as legal tender. Meanwhile, the World Bank has rejected the country’s request for assistance in implementing its Bitcoin Law over alleged environmental and transparency concerns. Nevertheless, El Salvador has remained steadfast in embracing Bitcoin and in creating an attractive environment for crypto investors and entrepreneurs. Last week, finance minister Alejandro Zelaya said the country’s Bitcoin Law has already attracted foreign investment.Čítaj viac
- Here’s 5 altcoins to study as crypto prices drop close to a 1-year low
- Fitch Ratings warns of risks crypto miners pose to US power supply
- There’s a browser plugin that autoblocks Twitter NFT profile pictures
- House members call for an end to lawmakers trading stocks — is crypto next?
- Analysts say Bitcoin’s bounce at $36K means “it’s time to start thinking about a bottom”